Here are all the tunes the Critic played on the 10/20 episode of The Critic’s Choice, recorded at Bohemian Bull on James Island
- Material Issue – Valerie Loves Me – International Pop Overthrow (1991)
- Suzanne Vega – Left of Center – Pretty in Pink (1986)
- Matt MacKelcan – Keep Me From Dreaming – Hearts Wide Open (2024)
- The English Beat – Best Friend – I Just Can’t Stop It (1980)
- Luscious Jackson – Ladyfingers – Electric Honey (1999)
- The Police – It’s Alright For You – Regatta de Blanc (1979)
- Sleater-Kinney – You’re No Rock n Roll Fun – All Hands on the Bad One (2000)
- Sebadoh – Skull – Bakesale (1994)
- Cheekface – Flies – It’s Sorted (2024)
- The Bangles – Here Takes a Fall – All Over the Place (1984)
- Guided by Voices – Chasing Heather Crazy – Isolation Drills (2001)
- Meat Puppets – Lake of Fire – Too High to Die (1994)
- Royel Otis – If Our Love is Dead – Pratts & Pain (2024)
- Fishbone – Ma and Pa – Truth & Soul (1988)
- Pernice Brothers – The Weakest Shade of Blue – Yours, Mine & Ours (2003)
- The Breeders – Divine Hammer – Last Splash (1993)